Project : Rooftop

Superheroes, Redesigned

P:R Approved: Andy MacDonald’s X-Men!

Note: The X-Men have always been some of the most relatable heroes in comics, and artist Andy MacDonald took that one step further with this recent redesigns of the team in normal street clothes. Posted over on his blog, these designs bring the color schemes the heroes wear in their uniforms while making them something  normal people could wear. The Gambit and Rogue pieces stand out as especially well-done pieces. – Chris A.

Editor’s Note: See more after the jump!

24 ResponsesLeave one →

  1. Edwin

     /  May 2, 2012

    Except for Scott looking a little TOO covered up, I like. It looks like something people would wear but still calls back everything it needs to for their costumes. I approve

  2. Andrew Kilian

     /  May 2, 2012

    Ahhhhhhh! Hipsters! The X-men are Hipsters! And they’re uncanny! Seriously, the designs are great, but I don’t see Wolverine going in for the Hipster look even if it is with a Southwestern vibe.

  3. G

     /  May 2, 2012

    Damn, I wanted to be the first to jump in with the first incredibly tedious and predictable “hipsters” comment. Damn.

    I like Storm a lot.

  4. Tim

     /  May 2, 2012

    I like them, except Scott’s color scheme needs tweaking. I can’t see him in yellow and purple.

  5. These drawings are really fun, but I think Cyclops’s cardigan and Gambit’s waistcoat button the wrong way. Men’s clothes have the buttons on the (wearer’s) right-hand side, so the left-hand layer should be outermost.

  6. Bryan

     /  May 2, 2012
  7. I really like these (then again, I’m a big fan of ‘normal clothes as costume’ in general. Particularly, I vastly prefer Gambit’s costume to his normal one (though the waistcoat has the buttons on the wrong side) – for some reason, though, I’m getting a Doctor Who vibe from it…

    My one real criticism is Storm’s heels – I think something in a yellow slip-on would go better with that outfit, in my opinion (but that may just be my bias against high heels on superheroes coming though)

  8. Benjamin Lyons

     /  May 2, 2012

    I adore these. The color is right out of Claremont/Byrne X-Men.

  9. avantsweater

     /  May 2, 2012

    Storm and Wolverine are amazing.

    Anorak Cyclops is a treat also.

  10. Danny

     /  May 2, 2012

    I particularly enjoy Wolverine’s Johnny Knoxville look here.

  11. Darcoth

     /  May 3, 2012

    These are great!
    Gambit is totally giving off a Jackie Estacado vibe, and it’s really awesome.
    I think for some of them the colours need to be tweaked a bit, though. Wolverine’s jacket, for example, might look better in a brown or tan. And Cyclops would perhaps benefit from a darker shade of blue. I don’t particularly like Cyclops’ waistcoat (or is it a cardigan?) the yellow on top of the yellow shirt doesn’t quite work for me.

  12. shiela

     /  May 3, 2012

    bfnh: storm looks like a pic i saw recently http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-K1pt92NzBJo/T5h4t0bsC3I/AAAAAAAAEXM/aPNr4naeYlY/s1600/259660734735823512_9GyogWlx_f.jpg on a fashion blog.

    Haha! Nice find. He must have been “inspired” by that fashion shoot photo.

  13. Itlas

     /  May 3, 2012

    pretty,but nothing more Smallville tv series didn’t already

  14. Edwin

     /  May 3, 2012

    Scott’s wearing a cardiagan. Waist coats don’t work that way, really. Didn’t beyonce wear something like Storm’s outfit once?

    Isn’t anyone gonna talk about how nice Rogue looks?

  15. bfnh

     /  May 3, 2012

    Bryan:
    Sartorialist?

    sartorialist via the man repeller.
    http://www.manrepeller.com/2012/04/inspired.html

  16. The Storm, and the Gambit are amazing! Storm has historically been willing to show it all, but this is the best of both worlds, sexy not slutty! AMAZING!

  17. Oooooo, loving the Gambit design! Great work!

  18. DaniSpite

     /  May 9, 2012

    This Gambit reminds me of Chuck Austen’s and Esad’s Ribic Ultimate X-Men fill-in issues, but adding his traditional colors. I always like when he loses some of the spandex for more casual clothes, and specially when his hair is let wild.

  19. These are great and Andy is a really underrated artist! Love his style.

    And these are NOT “hipster” X-Men!!! I’m so tired of people applying that word to ANY fashionable or contemporary version/redo of a character. If you want to use the word “hipster”, please research what a real hipster is.

  20. Branden

     /  May 30, 2012

    I like Cyclops(nice reference to the WASP-y nature of the first X-Men) and Gambit(a toned down version of his classic costume, but still references the silly patterns). Storm(too young looking) and Rogue(too old looking dispite the shoes) don’t work for me. Logan’s ok, its not too different than his non-costume costume he always wears, but the pattern on the jacket is a nice call-back to his classic costume design.

  21. B

     /  May 31, 2012

    Scott’s reads too much like a young Professor X, but I really like all of these. Gambit looks great. Put Storm in flats though! :)

  22. AJay

     /  July 11, 2012

    I’m SO glad Storm doesn’t have a mohawk in this rendition! Cyclops looks…a little cluttered, though…

  1. Looking good! – nullrend

Leave a Reply